
Skip the mall. December on Long Island is full of markets where you buy gifts from the people who actually made them. These are the five we’d put on the calendar first.
Our No. 1 pick
A Very Merry Misfit-mas. Our own, so we’re biased, and we’re saying so. It’s free, it’s full of small-business makers, and Santa is there for free photos.
Holiday markets on Long Island, ranked
Everything you need to go. Tap Details for directions, the calendar and the official site.
A Very Merry Misfit-mas
Great South Bay Brewery · Bay Shore
A free holiday market full of small-business vendors, live music all day, free photos with Santa, and face painting, tinsel and henna. Bring a list and a big bag.
Details
Where: Great South Bay Brewery, 25 Drexel Drive, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Free, with free tickets on Eventbrite. A Stay Salted event.
Art League of Long Island Holiday Fine Art + Craft Fair
Art League of Long Island · Dix Hills
Six decades of tradition: fine art, jewelry, ceramics, woodwork and textiles from local artists. Gifts that look like you thought hard about them.
Details
Where: 107 East Deer Park Road, Dix Hills, NY 11746
Free admission.
Our free holiday market · Sat, Dec 12 · Bay Shore
A Very Merry Misfit-mas
Small-business makers, live music all day, free photos with Santa, face painting and more, at Great South Bay Brewery in Bay Shore. It’s free, and so are the tickets.
The Interwoven Art Market
Kasher Gallery + Studios · Northport
Original art, textiles, jewelry and weaving from local creators, on Small Business Saturday. Meet the makers and start your list.
Details
Where: 19 Scudder Avenue, Northport, NY
On the second floor of the gallery.
Holiday Market at Station Yards
Station Yards · Ronkonkoma
A curated market of Long Island artists and makers, with a tree lighting on Saturday night.
Details
Where: 9 Hawkins Avenue, Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
Across from the Ronkonkoma LIRR station. Holiday tree lighting Saturday at 5 pm.
Annual Holiday Market at Hofstra
Hofstra USA Building · Uniondale
The first big market of the season, the weekend after Thanksgiving. Get a head start on your list.
Details
Where: Hofstra USA Building, 215 Liberty Blvd, Uniondale, NY 11549
Hours and admission weren’t posted on the organizer’s site when we checked.
Quick answers
What are the best holiday markets on Long Island in 2026?
Our picks: A Very Merry Misfit-mas (Sat, Dec 12); Art League of Long Island Holiday Fine Art + Craft Fair (Sat + Sun, Dec 5 to 6); The Interwoven Art Market (Sat, Nov 28); Holiday Market at Station Yards (Sat, Dec 5); Annual Holiday Market at Hofstra (Fri to Sun, Nov 27 to 29). Check with each organizer before you go.
What’s the one to pick?
A Very Merry Misfit-mas. Our own, so we’re biased, and we’re saying so. It’s free, it’s full of small-business makers, and Santa is there for free photos.
Is A Very Merry Misfit-mas free?
Yes. It’s free, with free tickets on Eventbrite: Saturday, Dec 12, 2026, 12 to 6 pm at Great South Bay Brewery, 25 Drexel Drive, Bay Shore. Free photos with Santa, small-business makers and live music.
Before you go
- Go early. Markets are calmer in the first hour.
- Give each kid a small budget for one gift for someone they love. They’ll take it very seriously.
- Bring a tote bag, a card and a little cash.
- Ask the maker about the piece. It’s the best part, and it’s the story you’ll tell when you give the gift.
Running an event on Long Island? List it free on our calendar, or put it in front of more families with a Featured spot.
Keep exploring
Your December, sorted.
Grab your free Misfit-mas tickets, then see every event on Long Island by town and date.
Hours and details can change, so check with each organizer before you go. A Very Merry Misfit-mas is a Stay Salted event.